Introduction
Oak Ridge Boys – “Trying to Love Two Women”
When the Oak Ridge Boys released “Trying to Love Two Women” in 1980, they delivered more than just another country hit—they captured a story of emotional conflict that resonated with audiences across the nation. The song, with its catchy melody and memorable harmonies, became one of the group’s signature tracks, earning them a number-one spot on the Billboard Hot Country Singles chart and solidifying their place at the forefront of country music.
Written by Sonny Throckmorton, “Trying to Love Two Women” tells the tale of a man caught in the emotional tug-of-war between two relationships. It’s a confession wrapped in melody—honest, conflicted, and undeniably human. The lyrics explore the challenges, guilt, and divided loyalties that come with such a situation, striking a chord with listeners who recognized the raw truth beneath the upbeat rhythm.
Musically, the song is a perfect showcase for the Oak Ridge Boys’ trademark four-part harmony. Duane Allen’s smooth lead vocals carry the narrative, while Joe Bonsall’s soaring tenor, William Lee Golden’s rich baritone, and Richard Sterban’s deep, resonant bass blend together to create a sound that is instantly recognizable. The arrangement is lively and engaging, masking the seriousness of the subject matter with an almost playful energy—a contrast that made the song even more compelling.
The track appeared on the Oak Ridge Boys’ album Together, which was part of the band’s remarkable run of success during the late 1970s and early 1980s. At the time, the group was known for bridging the gap between traditional country and more contemporary influences, bringing their music to a wider audience without losing touch with their roots. “Trying to Love Two Women” was a prime example of that formula at work—rooted in classic country storytelling, yet polished with a modern production style.
The song’s success also reinforced the Oak Ridge Boys’ reputation as a group unafraid to take on themes that were both relatable and controversial. Love triangles have long been a staple of country music, but this track stood out for the way it balanced honesty with accessibility, turning a morally complicated situation into a sing-along hit.
Over the years, “Trying to Love Two Women” has remained a favorite among fans, often included in the group’s live performances. On stage, it becomes more than just a song—it’s an opportunity for the Oak Ridge Boys to connect with audiences through humor, harmony, and shared experience. The crowd’s reaction, often a mix of knowing smiles and enthusiastic applause, speaks to the song’s lasting appeal.
Today, more than four decades after its release, “Trying to Love Two Women” still feels fresh. Its themes of love, temptation, and human imperfection are timeless, and the Oak Ridge Boys’ performance ensures that it continues to stand as one of the era’s most memorable country hits. It’s a reminder of the group’s unique ability to take life’s complicated truths and turn them into music that entertains, engages, and endures.